Quantcast
Channel: Marineford - All Forums
Viewing all articles
Browse latest Browse all 4747

Harry Potter - Chat & Discussion

$
0
0
İmage

Harry Potter - Chat & Discussion

I feel like making a new thread for every little topic isn't worth it, so let's use this general thread for all sorts of HP discussions.

If you look for our existing HP threads, use: Harry Potter Threads

Do you have something on your mind that you wanna share, a question, a rant, maybe something you always wondered or you just spotted while re-reading, re-listening, or re-watching the series? Then let us know. :)



I'll start:

Topic: Plot Holes & Things That Don't Make Sense

As amazing as JKR is for creating such a huge world with many connected story elements throughout the entire series, I cannot help but wonder about some things in the plot, e.g.:

- Biggest one first:
Spoiler: Voldemort not simply taking the prophecy.
So in the entire 5th book, Voldy tries to get the prophecy to finally hear the complete message, but only he and Harry can touch it. When Harry asks why Voldemort didn't just come and take it himself, we are told (by Bellatrix) that the Dark Lord cannot risk to be seen (since the wizarding world refuses to accept his return) and hence they had to make Harry get it.

Problem #1: The Death Eaters managed to empty the ENTIRE ministry of magic, so that a group of noiy kids can enter it. If the ministry is empty, Voldy can just go and take the prophecy in the first place. XDD Why wait for hours in the hopes that Harry arrives, when they are able to clear the entire freaking ministry and Voldy could just go in and out in 5minutes? I mean the ministry is empty after all, why not just take it yourself? (FP)

Problem #2: Voldy is the most powerful wizard in the world when it comes to magic skill, if he wanted to stay undetected and unseen, he could have done that easily. Especially when the whole ministry is empty in the firts place. xD

Problem #3: Voldy DID appear after all. So instead of taking the prophecy yourself when the ministry is empty, he waits until Harry & Co. have caused huge chaos & noise, and only appears when outsiders were probably already alarmed... brilliant. (T)

Viewing all articles
Browse latest Browse all 4747

Trending Articles